How to Make Amish Sweet Bread

Taylor Roatch
By Taylor Roatch August 8, 2017 09:52

How to Make Amish Sweet Bread

If you’ve never done it before, making bread can seem a bit daunting, prone to disaster at every turn. It’s not really so bad as all that, though. While it’s obviously more time consuming to make bread from scratch than it is to buy it, learning how could make your life much easier if society as we know it ever collapses.

You see, there’s a reason that bread has been a dietary staple for eons, long before food came from grocery stores. For one, it’s satisfying. Bread fills us up and gives a sense of satiation due to its high carbohydrate content. Carbs, while demonized by today’s fad diets, are a fast way to get energy. It contains many vitamins and minerals we need, too. Bread is also flexible in its formulation. It can be made from the most basic ingredients with little special equipment. Its history traces back to the Stone Age, where tools of all kinds were simple and few and far between.

Related: How To Build an Earthen Oven: DIY Easy Tutorial With Pictures

In today’s society, the art of baking bread has become something of a specialty as bread is so readily available on supermarket shelves. The Amish in many places have maintained their tech-free, non-consumerist lifestyle, and therefore continue to make their own bread. Here are the 5 lost survival lessons I learned from the Amish.

Bread Basics

There are several types of bread, including batter bread, sourdough, and yeast bread. Batter bread is more cake-like and you don’t need to allow it to rise before baking. Sourdough bread uses what’s known as a starter, which you can create by allowing flour and water to ferment, to help the dough rise, creating a loftier bread. Sourdough is an ideal type of bread to make in a SHTF situation because you only need the most basic, easily obtainable ingredients, but starter takes time to properly ferment and you have to continue feeding it so that the fermentation process continues. There is no shortcut, unless you can talk someone into sharing some of their starter, which you’ll still need to feed. The famous Amish Friendship Bread is made using a basic sourdough starter like this, hence the name. Women would share their starter with friends and family. Yeast bread uses, you guessed it, yeast to help raise the dough. We’re making a yeast bread here, but the yeast in this recipe can easily be replaced with a sourdough starter.

The great thing about baking bread is that once you understand the basic science behind it, you can make adjustments to the process and recipes as you see fit. This flexibility makes it a great skill for survival situations.

This particular recipe is great as an all-around bread. You can cut down the sugar some if you’re looking for a more savory bread.

Getting Started

For this yeast-risen Amish sweet bread, you will need the following:

  • 2 cups of warm water (110° F)
  • 2/3 cup granulated white sugar
  • One packet dry active yeast
  • 2 teaspoons of salt
  • ¼ cup vegetable oil
  • 6 cups white flour

Now, time to get down to the business of learning to make Amish sweet bread.

  1. Put sugar and warm water in a bowl, stir until dissolved. Now add the yeast packet. Let it sit until the mixture becomes foamy on the top. This means that the yeast has proofed and it’s ready to bake with. If your yeast doesn’t begin to foam up within about ten minutes, it may not be active anymore, or your water may be too cool or too hot. To get your water at the right temperature without a thermometer, put ½ cup of water in the microwave for one minute and add to the other 1 ½ cups of room temperature water. This should put it at right about the correct temperature, and if that doesn’t work, the yeast is likely no longer active. Yeast doesn’t live forever, so you may need to buy new. Carefully store yeast you’ve bought so that it’s not exposed to extreme temperatures or moisture.amish sweet bread making the dough yeast and water

If you’re using sourdough starter, this step is essentially eliminated and replaced with the creation of the starter. You’d simply add moreliquid and sugar to a measured amount of starter, and then continue on with the directions.

  1. Once the yeast mixture is proofed, add the oil and salt and stir.
  2. Now, you’ll need to add in the flour, but not all at once. Mix it in one cup at a time, making sure it’s well incorporated before adding the next cup.amish sweet bread making the dough1
  3. Put the dough on a floured surface and knead for a few minutes until smooth. Kneading is essentially just smooshing and squeezing the dough, mixing it by hand. making amish sweet breadThis abuse helps give the dough elasticity by stretching the infamous gluten fibers until they become more structured.amish sweet bread loafs 1
  4. Place the dough into an oiled bowl. Turn it over to coat the dough ball with the oil. Now, cover the bowl with a damp cloth. Tea towels or flour sack towels are perfect for this. Leave it to rise until it’s doubled in size. It should take about an hour, but it is really dependent on how active the yeast is and how well suited the environment is for raising bread.
  5. Punch down the dough and divide it into two equal parts.amish sweet bread dough ready for loafs
  6. Form the dough half into a loaf-like shape and place each in a 9×5 loaf pan that has been oiled.amish sweet bread dough in trays
  7. Allow the dough to raise again until it doubles in size, or until it fills the pans.
  8. Bake in a 350° F oven for 30 minutes.
  9. If you’d like, butter the top of each loaf while it’s still hot.
  10. Let the bread cool in the pans for ten minutes or so. Then, remove the bread from the pans by turning them upside down over a baking rack. Turn the bread right-side up and allow it to cool completely.
  11. Slice the bread carefully. This is one of the biggest challenges with satisfying homemade bread. There’s a reason for the expression ‘The greatest thing since sliced bread’. To get neat, non-squashed slices, use a sharp, serrated bread knife, or even employ an electric knife.

Baking bread isn’t as hard as it may seem from the outside. Once you’ve practiced up a bit, it can be simple and rewarding, so long as you’re willing to wait a bit for the fantastic, delicious finished product.

You may also like:

surv md bannerPioneer Recipes That Survived The California Trail

Why Walmart’s are Closing all Over America (video)

Six Primitive Traps For Catching Game In The Woods

10 Long Shelf-Life Canned Foods Every Prepper Should Consider Stockpiling


Please Spread The Word - Share This Post
Taylor Roatch
By Taylor Roatch August 8, 2017 09:52
Write a comment


  1. sha August 10, 15:11

    When you get the dough ready to bake how much dough do you take before you bake the dough. What do you do when you use the starter dough? The same amount of flour? Thanks

    Reply to this comment
    • TheSouthernNationalist August 10, 16:49

      You only need a small lump to keep as a starter.
      Check out James Townsend and Son videos on youtube.
      They are an 18th and 19th century reenactors store and they have some really great videos on bread and a cooking series, preppers can learn a lot from them.

      Reply to this comment
    • Homesteader August 10, 18:02

      Not all breads require a starter like sourdough bread does. The dough made from the recipe is what you bake – simply divide in half, rise, and bake. I’m going to make this recipe either later today or tomorrow. I like simple bread recipes and this one appears to fit the bill.

      Reply to this comment
  2. Jan August 10, 16:41

    Yes,, this recipe makes two loaves. It is the standard yeast bread recipe found in Betty Crocker, the Sourdough starter/ friendship bread follows. BTW, Sugar is the food for the yeast to grow.

    Reply to this comment
  3. Dave August 10, 17:29

    Wow! A recipe even this 66 yr old guy can do! Thanks!

    Reply to this comment
  4. Zellie August 10, 18:33

    Love it, can’t wait to get started, this has been on my list to do for a very long time. I remember my Grandmother and Dad making homemade bread for us when we were young, in the 1950’s/1960’s. Grandma was born in 1905, she made the most delicious cinnamon buns, plus was an excellent all round cook. My Dad took after her.

    Reply to this comment
    • Roch August 10, 23:12

      There’s nothing like it . The whole house smells like bread ..sooo good and I usually eat a whole loaf with butter lol hard not to ..add your flour gradually might not need the last cup of flour as you’ll be using some for kneading … enjoy!!!

      Reply to this comment
  5. Homesteader August 11, 23:29

    I made this bread today. It’s flavor reminders us of King’s Hawaiian bread. This recipe is definitely a keeper.

    Reply to this comment
  6. Barbara in SC August 13, 13:22

    I made this bread yesterday with gluten free flour, turbinado sugar and olive oil. Even though it did not rise enough because of my lack of experience and the age of the yeast, I will be trying again. The process was as easy as making a loaf of bread from a bread mix and the flavor is good.

    Reply to this comment
    • emmer January 11, 19:56

      gluten free flour doesn’t rise well because it is the 2 gluten-containing proteins in wheat that have the strong bonds to allow the rise. rye also has gluten, but somewhat less and barley has a bit. i would suggest a more neutral oil unless you are specifically wanting an italian style bread.

      Reply to this comment
  7. Junebug August 14, 20:31

    So happy to have found this site. Many of my recipes have been lost.

    Reply to this comment
    • Barbara in SC August 14, 22:10

      I know what you mean. Lost so many moving over the years. I am hunting for a Civil War era recipe passed down to my ex-husband’s grandmother. Lemon Cheesecake, 10 eggs, 6 lemons, flour and sugar. The lemons make a clear frosting.

      Reply to this comment
  8. jrh142 September 13, 19:51

    Can you use oat flour as well?

    Reply to this comment
    • Running Stump May 28, 20:57

      You can always try it no one says that you can not. It may turn out different than what you expect, but that is how you learn. I once made brownies with Rye flour. It wasn’t all that good but would do in a pinch. I took it to work, and it got eaten, or at least people tried to eat it I did not check the trash cans, so I’m not really sure.

      Reply to this comment
  9. vocalpatriot October 27, 19:34

    oh my! what a nice pair of buns!! lol

    Reply to this comment
  10. Willie September 7, 16:17

    Been making bread for 80 years. way to young to stop now. Love yo read of others ideas and recipes. Thanks for this site, very enjoyable. Willa

    Reply to this comment
  11. Willie September 7, 16:26

    P.S. I am on the Starch diet, and thankfully, Bread is on the menu. I am 89 years old, overweight, and have lost 11# this week I’ll never go back to eat all that food that is so bad for us. I’m never hungry and loosing like crazy. Willa

    Reply to this comment
  12. 1WVBBQueen December 26, 23:08

    I buy my Yeast in 1 pound packages from Sams Club, and was wondering how much Yeast would I use from my big package equivalent to the 1 package in this recipe???

    Reply to this comment
  13. Bruce February 11, 02:10

    Sorry but Amish wouldn’t use and Electric Knife.

    Reply to this comment
View comments

Write a comment


Follow Us